What Is Economic Stagnation?

Economic stagnation, a prolonged period of slow or no growth in an economy, poses significant challenges for both policymakers and investors. This articles explores the definition of stagnation and its impact on financial markets.

Understanding economic stagnation

Economic stagnation refers to a sustained period where an economy experiences minimal or no growth, often reflected in the GDP growth rate. An annual GDP growth rate below 2-3% is generally seen as a sign of stagnation.

This phase is typically marked by widespread unemployment and underemployment, signaling that the economy is not achieving its full potential. Economic stagnation may be a short-term phase or it may indicate a more persistent structural issue within the economy.

Stagnation can impact whole economies or be confined to particular sectors or businesses. Addressing economic stagnation typically necessitates adjustments in monetary policy or proactive fiscal measures to kickstart economic activity.

Examples in history

Throughout history, several countries have faced periods of economic stagnation, characterized by prolonged low or no growth. Here are some notable examples:

• United States. The USA experienced economic stagnation during the Long Depression following the Panic of 1873, with periods of stagnation mixed with growth until steadier growth resumed around 1896. The Great Depression in the 1930s was another significant period of stagnation that lasted until World War II.
• Japan. Often referred to as the Lost Decade, Japan has been experiencing economic stagnation since the early 1990s following the collapse of its asset price bubble. This period of stagnation has extended into the 21st century.
• Latin America. Many Latin American countries have had a long history of economic stagnation, with frequent economic crises and slow growth, particularly in the 2010s when per capita economic growth slowed significantly.

These instances highlight that stagnation can occur anywhere and can last from several years to decades.

How does economic stagnation affect financial markets?

Economic stagnation can have significant impacts on financial markets. These effects manifest in various ways across different asset classes, investor behavior, and market dynamics. Here are some of the key impacts.

• Stock market

Stagnation typically leads to lower consumer spending and business investment, reducing corporate revenues and profits. This can lead to lower stock prices and diminished returns for investors.

Uncertainty about economic prospects can lead to increased volatility in stock markets as investors react to negative news and adjust their expectations. They might shift their focus to defensive stocks, such as utilities, healthcare, and consumer staples, which tend to perform relatively better during economic downturns.

• Bond markets

Central banks often lower interest rates to stimulate the economy during periods of stagnation. This can lead to higher bond prices, as existing bonds with higher interest rates become more valuable.

Investors may seek the relative safety of government bonds, especially those from stable economies, leading to lower yields on these bonds. At the same time, corporate bonds, especially those with lower credit ratings, may see increased risk premiums as the likelihood of defaults rises during stagnation.

• Currency markets

An economy experiencing stagnation may see its currency weaken relative to stronger economies, as lower interest rates and reduced economic activity can lead to decreased investor confidence.

Investors might move their funds to currencies of more stable economies or those perceived as safe havens, such as the US dollar or the Swiss franc.

• Commodity markets

Reduced industrial activity and consumer spending can lead to lower demand for commodities, depressing prices for oil, metals, and agricultural products.

Depending on the broader economic context, stagnation can either contribute to deflation (due to reduced demand) or inflation (if coupled with supply-side constraints).

• Real estate markets

Stagnation can lead to decreased investment in real estate, both residential and commercial, as consumer confidence wanes and businesses scale back expansion plans. Lower demand can lead to stagnant or falling property prices, affecting real estate investment returns and leading to potential losses for investors.

Conclusion: Economic stagnation

Economic stagnation can lead to lower asset prices, increased market volatility, and shifts in investor preferences towards safer investments. The extent and nature of these effects depend on the specific context and the policy responses enacted to address the stagnation.

Follow us on Telegram, Instagram, and Facebook to get Headway updates instantly.