Buyback: What Is It and Why Do Companies Do It?

In corporate finance, the term “buyback” frequently pops up in news headlines, especially when major companies announce plans to repurchase their own stock. But what exactly does a buyback mean, and why do companies engage in this financial strategy? In this article, we’ll explain what a buyback is, how it works, and why companies undertake buybacks.

What is a buyback?

A buyback (also known as a share repurchase) occurs when a company buys its own outstanding stock shares. This is typically done through a tender offer or on the open market. Essentially, the company is purchasing shares that it had previously issued, reducing the total number of shares outstanding.

There are various ways a company can repurchase its shares:

1. Open market buyback. The company buys shares on the open market, just like any investor.
2. Tender offer. The company offers to buy back shares from existing shareholders at a premium over the current market price.
3. Private negotiation. The company negotiates with a specific shareholder to buy back a portion of their shares.

Buybacks are generally seen as a way for a company to invest in itself. By reducing the number of outstanding shares, it can increase the ownership percentage of existing shareholders and potentially boost the stock price.

Why do companies do buybacks?

Companies engage in share buybacks for several reasons, each tied to their overall financial strategy and goals. Below are some of the primary motivations behind buyback programs.

• Increasing share value. By reducing the number of shares available on the open market, buybacks inflate earnings per share (EPS). This often leads to further increases in the stock’s market price. Investors view buybacks as a positive sign that the business has ample cash.
• Undervaluation and investor returns. Companies may launch buybacks because they believe their shares are undervalued. Reducing the number of existing shares increases the proportion of earnings that each share represents. If the same price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is maintained, the stock price rises.
• Avoiding dilution. Companies issue stock rewards and options to employees and executives. Buybacks help avoid dilution of existing shareholders by repurchasing shares and issuing them to employees.
• Financial attractiveness. A share repurchase demonstrates that the business has sufficient cash reserves and low economic risk. It’s an alternative to dividends, as it uses retained earnings for the buyback.
• Optimizing capital structure. Companies often engage in buybacks as part of an effort to optimize their capital structure. A balanced mix of equity (stocks) and debt (bonds or loans) is key to a company’s financial health. By repurchasing shares, a company may adjust its capital structure, reducing the equity portion in favor of increasing its debt, which might be cheaper.
• Tax efficiency. In some jurisdictions, capital gains taxes on the sale of shares may be lower than dividend taxes. For shareholders, buybacks can be a tax-efficient way to receive value from a company compared to receiving dividends. Shareholders who sell their shares back to the company during a buyback may face a lower tax burden than if they received a dividend payout.

How do buybacks affect dividends?

Dividends represent income for the current year. Companies pay them from after-tax profits to shareholders. Investors include dividends in their annual income taxes. Dividends contribute significantly to an investment’s return.

When a company conducts a share repurchase (buyback), it aims to reduce outstanding shares. Buybacks improve per-share profitability metrics like EPS. They signal confidence in the company’s future. By reducing shares, buybacks enhance returns on equity and assets.

When a company buys back shares, it needs to pay out fewer dividends. Buybacks preserve capital and increase returns for remaining shareholders.

Potential downsides of buybacks

While buybacks can be beneficial for both companies and shareholders, they’re not without their risks and criticisms. Some of the potential downsides include:

• Short-term focus. Critics argue that buybacks may be a short-term tactic to boost stock prices at the expense of long-term investments in innovation, research, and growth. By focusing on repurchasing shares, a company might neglect investments that could lead to sustained growth.
• Risk of overpaying. If a company buys back its shares when the stock is overvalued, it may not be getting the best return on its capital. Overpaying for shares can result in poor use of resources and may not create long-term value for shareholders.
• Debt financing. In some cases, companies may borrow money to fund buybacks. If the company’s future cash flow is unable to cover the debt, it could lead to financial strain and increased risk.

Ultimately, whether a buyback is beneficial depends on how it aligns with the company’s overall financial health, its strategic goals, and the market’s perception of its long-term value. For investors, understanding the reasons behind a company’s buyback program is key to determining its potential impact on stock performance.

If you’re considering investing in companies that engage in share buybacks, it’s essential to weigh the benefits against the potential risks, keeping an eye on the company’s broader strategy and financial stability.

Follow us on Telegram, Instagram, and Facebook to get Headway updates instantly.